![]() This is another advantage to DP IMO, the "system overload" message in Logic is annoying, it's too responsive and to compensate Apple does whatever it can to turn on aggravating "features" like it's little pause on record armed tracks that you aren't currently playing, resulting in momentary note drops etc. Some of the same things apply, some virtual instruments spike the CPU, but honestly having the Audio Performance meter on during composing is probably a bad idea, to this day I don't here the intermittent spikes that the meter shows, and as soon as you're done composing it goes into PreGen anyway, with no spikes. Right now, on the MacBook Air here I can get far more instances of Diva running in DP than other DAWs including Logic, the PreGen feature is working really well in DP11 on the M1. I recently got into it on Facebook with someone about this. I hope I will not make people angry here. I will most likely buy DP 11 with my mac studio (when I order it!) but I would like to see if Logic can be a better option regarding optimization? DP, on the other hand, and probably because it's a smaller player in the market, has excellent compatibility in terms of importing and exporting to & from other platforms - not to mention the best compliance to MIDI file & broadcast WAVE specs (in terms of encoding the correct meta-data into the files) of all them, including Pro Tools.Īny idea if there is a possibility that logic will be more compatible and run smoother (better management in memory and CPU) in the new mac studio? ![]() If you need to collaborate and need to send (eg.) MIDI files and/or audio stems back and forth with different platforms (DAW or scoring etc.) then it really starts to get frustrating with all of its quirks and caveats. ![]() Logic does seem to work best as a stand-alone music production solution, where a project starts and finishes in Logic (although, IMO, the audio editing is abominable). It will depend a lot on what you want to use it for. I get the distinct impression that Apple does a bare minimum of development on it and as a result there are several functions in the app that still just don't work properly (which is fine, I guess, if you don't need those functions). Logic seems to have barely changed since the 'update' from Logic 9 to Pro X (essentially Garageband Pro). I use both DP & Logic professionally, and have a fair bit of experience with both. Although the same can be said for FinalCut Pro, it sells high performance Macs. Apple does improve it now and then but it's not a priority. Logic exists for one purpose only: It sells Macs. Audio is an afterthought but fortunately, we get to benefit. That's what the Studio is designed to crunch. I expect the in-depth testing comparisons to be between AV and rendering apps such as FCPx vs Premiere, MAYA vs Unity, Blender, Key Shot, Cinema 4D etc. The new Studio is such a beast that efficiency for any current audio DAW should not be a problem. I use the tool I need for the task at hand. I've been using DP for 25 years and Logic for over a dozen-the subject has never interested me and I can't believe it ever will. If anyone wants to make that kind of time, they can knock themselves out. Ohhhh, this won't stop a bunch of YouTubers from comparing Audacity vs Reaper vs other cheapware. The only way to know for certain is to test both and do it correctly. There's always a possibility, one way or the other.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |